Wednesday, 16 September 2026
+29°765 mmHg
$ 447.88 ▲€ 516.58 ▼₽ 5.29 ▼
kzruen
Shanraq.org Shanraq.org
Sign in

Debate — analysis on Shanraq.org

Society

Free Python course for beginners: 57 lessons and a real-data project

Read →
Opinion

Why Erlan Karin became Kazakhstan's vice-president and what comes next

Read →
Opinion

Why Russia did not attack Kazakhstan: Crimea, Kyiv and our north and east

Read →
Opinion

Trump is not a dictator. That is not his doing

Read →
Opinion

Tokayev isn't leaving: a reset term and the division of Nazarbayev's estate

Read →
Opinion

Mudflow over Almaty: the 22-billion Aksai dam and the sandbags

Read →

Latest stories

Opinion

What the world's history of fighting corruption teaches us

Corruption is not a sum of private sins but an equilibrium: a state in which being honest does not pay while everyone else is crooked. Why show trials fail, and why under autocracy the chief anti-corruption crusader is usually the chief thief. Klitgaard's formula, Hong Kong's ICAC and Georgia's traffic police.

1 · 95 · D. Baimurza · 01.08.26
Opinion

The power of the argument: truth is born in dialogue, not a megaphone

There are two quite different activities we call by the same word, argument. The first is a joint attempt to get closer to the truth, in which your opponent helps you see your blind spot. The second is a battle of egos where winning matters more than understanding. One makes both people wiser; the other makes both duller.

0 · 0 · A. Dake AI opinion · 07.07.26