Shanraq.org Shanraq.org

Shanraq.org — independent analysis and free courses: Kazakhstan, economy, programming

Latest stories

Society

Free Python course for beginners: 57 lessons and a real-data project

Shanraq’s open course teaches Python through one continuous project. Learners collect data from official sources, validate and analyse it, then turn their work into a reproducible report. Here is who the 57 lessons are for, how the learning path works, and why money is a subject to investigate rather than a conclusion supplied in advance.

Opinion

Trump is not a dictator. That is not his doing

For weeks he refused to rule out military force against Greenland. European troops arrived and eight governments publicly backed Denmark. On 21 January he ruled force out. Greenland, tariffs, Iran, a third term — four times he reached a wall, and not once did he stop himself.

Opinion

Mudflow over Almaty: the 22-billion Aksai dam and the sandbags

A glacier collapse in Nepal killed more than 350 people, with almost no warning possible. The mudflow dam above Almaty is the opposite: its danger is known in advance. It should shield thirty thousand people, and has stood unfinished for six years. 22 billion tenge spent, the site mothballed, its bank reinforced with sandbags.

Society

Four Countries Closed the Border — We Opened a Stadium

Britain, Australia, Poland and Switzerland each said publicly why they would not let Ye in. On 15 August he walked onto the Central Stadium in Almaty: 31,000 people, five billion tenge. He played the old hits — nothing he was barred for. What Kazakhstan argued about for a week was the grass.

Culture

Three Hundred and Eighty-Six People

A language was safe as long as enough people spoke it. That rule has stopped working: machines learn from text, and a machine's ability to speak a language depends on how much has been written in it. Iceland, with 386,000 people, has 215 active encyclopedia editors; Kazakhstan, with twenty million, has just 386.

Society

Measles conducted an audit of Kazakhstan's reporting

The WHO records 15,111 measles cases in Kazakhstan for 2023 and 28,147 for 2024 — forty-three thousand people. Beside that stands the official vaccination coverage figure: 99%. The two do not add up. We recounted the whole world and examine how the discrepancy surfaced and what it says about official reporting.

World

Ukraine refused to be a herd. We have not — yet

On 5 December 1994 in Budapest three near-identical papers were signed — with Ukraine, Kazakhstan and Belarus. Ukraine gave up 1,900 warheads, Kazakhstan 1,410. Both started from the same point: $1,483 per head there, $1,442 here. The difference turned out not to be money, but whether power ever retreated before the street.

Economy

Astana Hub and the 35-year tradition of resetting

I am a member of Astana Hub, and I will say it plainly: the tax exemption works and a startup needs it — the rest gave me nothing. Hence the question: if only the exemption works, why does it need a technology park, a building and 1.5 billion tenge of rent a year? And why has no such project been audited in thirty-five years.

Economy

Shulhani: Trading in Money Is Haram

The shulhani was the money changer at his table in the Temple of Jerusalem, swapping foreign coin for the Tyrian shekel — the only currency the temple tax could be paid in. He took four to eight per cent and produced nothing: his income came from the fact that somebody else's payment was compulsory. Jesus overturned his tables.

Sport

The Wrong Table: Thirty Years of Olympics, Recounted Honestly

The medal table measures the size of a country before anything else: economists showed the result is predicted almost entirely by population and GDP. We recalculated all sixteen Olympics from 1994 to 2024 per head of population — the United States falls from 1st to 53rd, China from 2nd to 91st, India lands 131st of 132.

Economy

Palantir: The Company That Cannot Be Outvoted

People have argued about Palantir for twenty years, but about the wrong thing. It started in 2003 on money from the CIA's venture fund and hides nothing about what it does — its chief executive says so publicly. What matters is not the founders' rhetoric but the charter: one class of shares gives them 49.999999% of the vote.

Opinion

Subscribed From Above: The Price of Silence

Kazakhstan's state information order runs to about 67 billion tenge a year, while schools, hospitals and local administrations are still handed subscription quotas from above. What that money buys, how support for the press differs from a leash, and why the famine and Semipalatinsk are stories about a silent press.