Shanraq.org Shanraq.org

Economy — analysis on Shanraq.org

Latest stories

Economy

Astana Hub and the 35-year tradition of resetting

I am a member of Astana Hub, and I will say it plainly: the tax exemption works and a startup needs it — the rest gave me nothing. Hence the question: if only the exemption works, why does it need a technology park, a building and 1.5 billion tenge of rent a year? And why has no such project been audited in thirty-five years.

Economy

Shulhani: Trading in Money Is Haram

The shulhani was the money changer at his table in the Temple of Jerusalem, swapping foreign coin for the Tyrian shekel — the only currency the temple tax could be paid in. He took four to eight per cent and produced nothing: his income came from the fact that somebody else's payment was compulsory. Jesus overturned his tables.

Economy

Palantir: The Company That Cannot Be Outvoted

People have argued about Palantir for twenty years, but about the wrong thing. It started in 2003 on money from the CIA's venture fund and hides nothing about what it does — its chief executive says so publicly. What matters is not the founders' rhetoric but the charter: one class of shares gives them 49.999999% of the vote.

Economy

Money That Breeds: How Chrematistics Was Passed Off as Economics

Aristotle split household management in two: oikonomia, providing for real needs, and chrematistics, accumulating money for its own sake. The second won and named itself economics. Why the Greek called interest offspring, why all three Abrahamic faiths forbade usury, and what a central bank's refinancing rate really is.

Economy

The growth nobody felt: what Kazakhstans economy shows in mid-2026

GDP grew 4.1% in the first half of 2026, manufacturing 9.8%, private investment 21.4%. From the same statistics: real wages fell 2.3% in the first quarter, the worst result in the Eurasian Union, and retail trade halved its pace. Both figures are correct, and between them lies the whole of current economic policy.

Economy

What is really kept in a bank — money, or trust?

Picture the inside of a bank: there is no pile of coins matching your account. The money is working, lent out, invested. What actually lies in a bank is invisible and matters more than gold. While the belief holds, the system runs — although there is not enough real money for everyone at once. That is why a crisis looks like an epidemic of fear.

Economy

The dignity of labor: the invisible hands that hold up the world

Almost everything around you was made by somebody's hands: the bread, the road, the light in the room, the screen you are reading this on. We know the names of performers and bloggers but not of whoever brought water into the house. Their work becomes visible only when it suddenly is not there. A society is like a building.

Economy

Oil at War: Whose Windfall, Whose Illusion — A View from Kazakhstan

By mid-July a barrel of Brent costs about $78.82 — some 19% above the pre-war level, though early in the month the price had slipped back to seventy. The Strait of Hormuz, through which about 20% of the world's oil passes, is close to shut. Why for an exporting country this is both a gift to the budget and a trap.

Economy

Energy: the hidden currency of civilization

Everything has a price in money, but money has a price in energy. The cost of bread, metal and the internet is ultimately the cost of the energy spent. There is a treacherous quantity too: how much energy must go in to get one unit out. When oil gushed, one unit invested returned a hundred. Today resources come harder.

Economy

The right to fail: why courage matters more than a guarantee

Behind a handsome success story there is almost always a warehouse of failures nobody writes about. In a society that despises those who fail, people stop trying, and that costs more than any bankruptcy: we see the companies that went under, not the thousands of ideas never born for fear of shame.

Economy

Labor and automation: will professions disappear

Every wave of automation arrives under the same headline: the professions will disappear. More often something else happens — the profession changes its content. The cashier did not vanish when terminals arrived; they became an adviser. The accountant stopped adding columns and took up the meaning of the numbers.

Economy

Inflation: why prices rise and what to do about it

Inflation is when the same money buys less tomorrow than it does today. There are usually two causes: more money in the economy than goods, or costs themselves rising. It is unfair by nature: property rises along with prices while wages and savings lose value. What actually helps, and what only sounds like it does.

Economy

Bread matters more than oil: the quiet strategy of food

A country can buy oil, weapons and technology, but a country that cannot feed itself is never truly independent. Oil can be replaced or postponed; food cannot — people eat every day. Hunger has toppled rulers more often than armies have. Why farming countries hold a card that money cannot buy.

Economy

Money: a short history of trust

Money looks like a thing — coins, notes, figures in an account. In substance it is an agreement: a banknote has value not in itself but because everyone around has agreed to take it in exchange for work. First people trusted gold, then states, now increasingly code. Why inflation destroys not notes but trust.

Economy

Small business: why it matters more than it seems

The news talks about corporations and mega-projects, and a cafe, a workshop or a one-person firm look like small change. They are what creates most of the jobs. There is a less obvious role too: a person with a business of their own depends less on a single employer. Many independent people are what makes a society steady.

Economy

Trade: why exchange makes everyone richer

Trade is often taken for a zero-sum game: if someone won, someone else lost. Economics showed the opposite two hundred years ago — exchange is addition, not confiscation. But an honest conversation does not end there: the gain is spread thinly across everyone, while the loss falls on a few, at once and hard.

Economy

Inflation Hits Those Who Have Less

Inflation is discussed in percentages as though it were the weather, but behind the average figure hides a very unequal distribution of pain. For a comfortable household it is holidays and gadgets that get dearer; for a poor one it is bread, medicine, transport and rent — the things that cannot be given up.