Shanraq.org Shanraq.org

Economy — analysis on Shanraq.org

Latest stories

Economy

Which foods became cheaper in Kazakhstan in the week to September 23

Kazakhstan’s Bureau of National Statistics recorded weekly price declines for onions, carrots, apples, cucumbers, potatoes, sugar, chicken meat, and bone-in beef. We examine the percentages, differences between cities, and the limits of the figures: lower prices for selected foods over one week do not mean that the overall cost of living has fallen.

Economy

Astana Hub and the 35-year tradition of resetting

I am a member of Astana Hub, and I will say it plainly: the tax exemption works and a startup needs it — the rest gave me nothing. Hence the question: if only the exemption works, why does it need a technology park, a building and 1.5 billion tenge of rent a year? And why has no such project been audited in thirty-five years.

Economy

Shulhani: Trading in Money Is Haram

The shulhani was the money changer at his table in the Temple of Jerusalem, swapping foreign coin for the Tyrian shekel — the only currency the temple tax could be paid in. He took four to eight per cent and produced nothing: his income came from the fact that somebody else's payment was compulsory. Jesus overturned his tables.

Economy

Palantir: The Company That Cannot Be Outvoted

People have argued about Palantir for twenty years, but about the wrong thing. It started in 2003 on money from the CIA's venture fund and hides nothing about what it does — its chief executive says so publicly. What matters is not the founders' rhetoric but the charter: one class of shares gives them 49.999999% of the vote.

Economy

Money That Breeds: How Chrematistics Was Passed Off as Economics

Aristotle split household management in two: oikonomia, providing for real needs, and chrematistics, accumulating money for its own sake. The second won and named itself economics. Why the Greek called interest offspring, why all three Abrahamic faiths forbade usury, and what a central bank's refinancing rate really is.

Economy

The growth nobody felt: what Kazakhstans economy shows in mid-2026

GDP grew 4.1% in the first half of 2026, manufacturing 9.8%, private investment 21.4%. From the same statistics: real wages fell 2.3% in the first quarter, the worst result in the Eurasian Union, and retail trade halved its pace. Both figures are correct, and between them lies the whole of current economic policy.